The Broadway Theater is an abandoned theater in Monticello, New York, and is named after the street it is located on.

The theater was built in 1920 2 and had a capacity of 975 seats, opening only for the summer tourist season. 2 The building boasted two retail spaces along Broadway.

In 1986, Steven Klar, a lawyer and developer, purchased the Broadway Theater from Milton Kutscher, the owner of the Kitscher Hotel. 1 Klar renovated the building, re-upholstered the seats, cleaned the marquee and replaced the screen, and also opened an ice-cream parlor and candy store in the front storefronts.