Esther Manor is a former Catskills Mountain resort near Monticello, New York.
The grounds of Esther Manor began in 1905 10 as the Albert House. Named after Albert Montgomery Fulton, Jr., a graduate of Harvard University, 3 the hotel offered luxurious, kosher accommodations. 11 Recreational amenities included panoramic views of the Catskills and a lake, bathing, billiards, boating, dancing, fishing, golf and tennis. 12
Irene Goldstein Asman and her sister, Esther Goldstein Strassberg, founded Esther Manor. 1 4 Strassberg was reportedly the first Jewish employee of Sullivan County. 1
Esther Manor was thoroughly modernized in circa 1960. The renovations included:
- A new lobby.
- A new indoor swimming pool.
- A new card and television room.
- A new cocktail lounge and nightclub.
- A new luncheonette.
- A new air-conditioned dining room.
- Fully air-conditioned guest rooms with wall-to-wall carpeting and colourful bathrooms.
A fire on July 4, 1962, destroyed a rooming house for employees of the Esther Manor. 8 Four men were playing cards when an explosion occurred. One man was killed and another suffered minor burns. The main building of the hotel was damaged in a fire on July 12, 1962, although there were no reported injuries. 7 9 It caused an estimated $100,000 in destruction. 9 The fire was blamed on two employees smoking in a bed.
Neil Sedaka played in a band at Esther Manor in the 1950’s and 1960’s and where he met his wife, the daughter of the resort’s owners. 5 6
On March 23, 1970, Esther Manor was sold to Weight Watchers Resorts & Spas and then to the Maimonides Institute on May 22, 1974. 13 The Institute had been established under Jewish auspices in 1959 to assist mentally handicapped children and young adults regardless of ethnic background. 16 The Institute opened the Maimonides School within the former Esther Manor, taking in individuals from state schools and hospitals. 15
The school came under scrutiny in February 1978 after an audit revealed the school submitted more than $500,000 in excess claims, 15 double billing and inflating tuition rates to overcharge state agencies. 17 The Maimonides Institute closed shortly after.
The resort was then sold to Hadar Hatorah on November 30, 1979 13 when it became rabbinical seminary and summer camp for Hasidic Jewish children. and then to the Wheatley Wood Development Corporation on November 16, 1984.
Esther Manor later reopened as Camp David, another summer camp for Hasidic Jewish children. 14 Camp Esther / Camp Bias Esther, 2 a summer camp for up to 600 Hasidic Jewish children from the Brooklyn, opened in the former resort in 2006. 2 5
In October 2010, the inspectors from the township cited the camp for 99 violations. 5 Inspectors found raw sewage on the ground, indoor electrical wires hung outside in the trees, and numerous structural concerns, including collapsed porches, broken windows and broken doors. The township ordered the camp to close on June 28, 2011 after it didn’t correct any of the prior violations.
The camp hired an electrician to replace faulty wiring and an company was brought in to certify the alarm system. 5 Additionally, footing pads, posts and bracing was replaced on some of the units. After repairing 45 of the most serious of violations, the camp was allowed to open on July 13.
Camp Bias Esther later closed and reopened as Camp Shalva of Bobov before being abandoned circa 2012.
[su_spoiler title=”Sources” icon=”caret”]
- “Paid Notice: Deaths STRASSBERG, ESTHER GOLDSTEIN.” New York Times, 22 Jan. 2003.
- Solis, Marcus. “Camp shut down due to deplorable conditions.” WABC-TV, 29 Jun. 2011.
- Wheeler, A.D. “Abandoned Catskills Part II ~ Albert House.” The Explorographer, 9 Nov. 2015.
- “Irene Goldstein Asman.” Joseph N. Garlick Funeral Home.
- Whitman, Victor. “Sullivan Hasidic boys’ camp reopens.” Times Herald-Record [Middletown], 15 Jul. 2011.
- Whitman, Victor. “Religious boys camp in Sullivan allowed to reopen.” Times Herald-Record [Middletown], 14 Jul. 2011.
- “Liberty Hotel Blaze Kills 2, Injures 13.” Press and Sun-Bulletin [Binghamton], 13 Jul. 1962. pp. 1-2.
- “Man Loses Life As Fire Destroys Rooming House.” Times Record [Troy], 5 Sept. 1962. p. 21.
- “Man Held After 3 Die in Hotel Fire.” Times Record [Troy], 14 Jul. 1962. p. 3.
- “Beautiful Sullivan County.” New York Times, 11 Jun. 1905. p. 8.
- “Albert House.” New York Times, 29 May. 1906. p. 15.
- “The Albert House.” Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 7 Jun. 1914.
- “Ownership Record.” Sullivan County Tax Map and Records System.
- “Remembering the Catskill resorts.” Long Island Herald, 27 Aug. 2014.
- “School Audited.” Post-Star [Glen Falls], 21 Feb. 1978, p. 3.
- “Julie Eisenhower Accepts for Mother.” Kingston Daily Freeman, 28 Nov. 1971. p. 37.
- “Around the State.” Democrat and Chronicle [Rochester], 21 Feb. 1978. p. 2A.