The Penn-Lincoln Hotel is a former hotel along Penn Avenue in downtown Wilkinsburg, Pennsylvania. Abandoned in 1995, the derelict tower was demolished in 2014.
After the results of a survey were released, 9 125 business leaders of Wilkinsburg met at Dudley’s tea room in the Shield Building on September 24, 1925, and unanimously agreed to build a $650,000 hotel for travelers along the Lincoln Highway and the Pennsylvania Railroad. 4 A 21-person committee was appointed to start on plans for the new 150-room hotel, tentatively called the Lincoln-Penn. 10 The Wilkinsburg Hotel Company was formed 3 and architect Benno Janssen of Janssen & Cocken, 4 8 who was also the architect for the William Penn Hotel, Pittsburgh Athletic Club and the former Kaufmann’s Department Store in downtown Pittsburgh, was hired to design the building. 1
The proposed hotel site, at Penn Avenue and Center Street, included a frame house and several stores. 10 The lots were acquired for $80,000. 11 A contract for construction was awarded to E.Z. Peffer on May 3, 1926, with a targeted completion date of March 1, 1927.
The new six-story, 70,000 square-foot Penn-Lincoln Hotel was completed at the cost of $850,000 and was dedicated after a four-day ceremony on June 2, 1927. 8 The facility included 120 guest rooms decorated by Causey & Heitchue, a ballroom, a dining room, and a coffee shop. 3 8
The Penn-Lincoln was later converted into 65 apartments and offices. 5 In 1993, the building’s last tenant, a beauty shop that had been operated by Anna Nowak since 1944, closed. 13 The building was owned by Joseph and Nathan Nassif who owed more than $200,000 in back taxes by 1997. 12
The neglected Penn-Lincoln was purchased by Penn Hills businessman Mario Noce for $70,000 in 2005 who completed some basic repairs to the roof and interior. The former hotel was then acquired by Deliverance Inc., a local faith-based organization, 4 who partnered with the Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation in an attempt to renovate the building. 5 The Foundation loaned $135,000 to Deliverance for some repairs but the work was never completed. 7
Studies conducted in 2010 under a $75,000 contract with the Allegheny County Department of Economic Development assessed the market feasibility of restoration of the hotel. 4 The studies concluded that there was little market interest in the Penn-Lincoln due to the deteriorated condition of the building and the estimated $10 million 5 in renovation costs. 1
On July 3, 2012, the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Financing Authority approved $500,000 in Federal Community Development Block Grant funds towards the $580,715 cost of demolishing the Penn-Lincoln. 1 The state had previously approved of $88,215 towards the project. In May 2014, the decision was made to demolish the Penn-Lincoln and work to remove the hotel commenced soon after. 6
[su_spoiler title=”Sources” icon=”caret”]
- Spatter, Sam. “Wilkinsburg makeover funded.” Pittsburgh Tribine-Review. N.p., 3 July 2012. TribLive. Web. 5 Mar. 2014. Article.
- Spatter, Sam. “Federal grant money approved for Penn Lincoln Hotel demolition in Wilkinsburg.” Pittsburgh Tribine-Review. N.p., 18 Oct 2013. TribLive. Web. 5 Mar. 2014. Article.
- Wilkinsburg Historical Society. “Avenues of Commerce.” Wilkinsburg. Charleston: Arcadia, 2007. 64. Print.
- Olson, Thomas. “Old Wilkinsburg hotel could get new life as office, retail space.” Pittsburgh Tribine-Review. N.p., 15 Feb 2010. TribLive. Web. 5 Mar. 2014. Article.
- Barnes, Jonathan. “Study says Penn Lincoln Hotel could take $10 million to fix.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. N.p., 10 Mar. 2011. post-gazette.com. Web. 6 Mar. 2014. Article.
- Schooley, Tim. “Penn Lincoln hotel in Wilkinsburg soon to be demolished.” Pittsburgh Business Times. N.p., 5 May 2014. Web. 2 Jul. 2014. Article.
- “A Note on the Fate of the Former Penn-Lincoln Hotel Building.” Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation. N.p., 29 Apr. 2014. Web. 2 Jul. 2014. Article.
- “Wilkinsburg’s New Penn-Lincoln Hotel Opens.” Pittsburgh Gazette Times 2 Jun. 1927: 5. Print.
- “Wilkinsburg Hotel Project Indorsed.” Pittsburgh Daily Post 25 Sept. 1925: 2. Print.
- “Real Estate.” Pittsburgh Press 12 Jan. 1926: 7. Print.
- “Wilkinsburg Hotel Contract Awarded.” Pittsburgh Press 4 May 1926: 35. Print.
- Haynes, Monica L. and Torsten Ove. “Tax scofflaws face new pressure.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 27 Feb. 1997: East 2. Print.
- Place, M.J. “Mayor seeks place in history for Penn Lincoln Hotel.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 9 Jun. 1999: East 7. Print.